Knowledge management software is usually compared for teams writing wikis. Practice often looks different: in a law firm, a tax office, a library or an archive, the knowledge isn’t wiki pages, but documents. Contracts, notices, files, scans. And the first question there isn’t “which editor is prettier” but “where does the data live and who can reach it”.
So this comparison has a column the usual lists skip: hosting location. And a second look that’s usually missing: what the tools can do with documents, not just typed text.
The comparison
| Tool | Where the data lives | Built for | Open source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Confluence | Cloud (region selectable) / Data Center | Team wiki in the Atlassian world | No |
| Notion | US | Flexible team workspaces | No |
| Nuclino | EU (Germany) | Lightweight team wiki | No |
| Slite | EU | Docs for remote teams | No |
| BookStack | Your server | Self-hosted wiki | Yes |
| Obsidian | Your device | Personal linked notes | No (open files) |
| Capacities | EU | Personal structured notes | No |
| Memexa | EU (hosted only) | Documents + AI access via MCP | No (open export) |
Sorted by situation
The team writes wiki pages and lives in Jira: Confluence: the standard, sluggish but connectable to everything. The team wants it lighter: Nuclino (German company, EU-hosted, pleasantly reduced) or Slite. Full control, own servers, IT on hand: BookStack: open source, proven, free; maintenance is the price. Individual with text knowledge: Obsidian or Capacities (the detailed comparison is here).
The professional lens: law firms, tax offices, libraries, archives
Here the usual recommendations flip, for three reasons:
- The knowledge is documents. A wiki doesn’t help when the answer sits in a scanned notice from 2019. What’s needed is text recognition and search inside the document. The wiki camp (Confluence, Notion, Nuclino, Slite, BookStack) indexes attachments superficially at best.
- Data location is a duty, not a preference. Client and personal data on US servers is simply not an option for many firms and public bodies. That filters out Notion and makes the EU column above the first sorting question.
- Answers must be verifiable. “It’s somewhere in the file” doesn’t cut it. You need the citation: which document, which page.
That profile is exactly what Memexa is built for: documents and scans run through text recognition, get linked in a knowledge graph, and every answer names document and page. On top comes the part classic knowledge management software doesn’t have yet: the knowledge is usable by Claude or ChatGPT via MCP: “what did we decide about client X’s depreciation in 2023?” becomes a question to the AI, with a citation. EU-hosted, GDPR details here.
To be honest about it: Memexa is not a team wiki with page permissions and editing workflows. It is hosted only (your own servers aren’t an option) and not open source. If you need both, combine them: wiki for the processes, document memory for the files. The price: from €2.49 a month billed yearly (€29.90 a year) or €2.99 monthly (all plans).
Building a personal knowledge base
Not every knowledge base needs a team. For freelancers, researchers or your own household, a personal one is often enough, and it follows different rules from a team wiki:
- One place, not five. Notes in one app, contracts in Downloads, tax letters in your inbox: you only find what sits in one place. Pick the place to fit your material, not the nicest interface.
- Start with what you have. A few dozen existing PDFs, notes and scans are useful from day one. Folders and categories show up on their own after a few weeks.
- Make non-text searchable. A scan without text recognition is a blank page to every search. Check whether your tool reads scans before you commit.
- Link instead of filing. A document rarely fits exactly one folder. Links between notes and documents (by wikilink in Obsidian, automatically in a knowledge graph) carry further than any folder tree.
- Mind the exit. A personal knowledge base grows for years. It should export to an open format such as Markdown.
For plain text on one device, Obsidian or Capacities is enough. If your knowledge is mostly documents and you’d rather ask Claude or ChatGPT than a search box, a document memory like Memexa is the better fit. For personal paperwork, see Find your paperwork with AI. If all you need is one research project across a handful of documents, NotebookLM or one of the NotebookLM alternatives is often enough.
Frequently asked questions
What does it cost to start?
BookStack is free (plus a server), Nuclino and Slite start with free tiers, Confluence and Notion likewise. Memexa has no free tier: a 14-day trial (card required), then from €2.49 a month billed yearly or €2.99 monthly. For a tax office the more relevant math is usually search time: one citation you can’t find costs more than any monthly license.
Can you do knowledge management without the cloud?
Yes. BookStack (your server) and Obsidian (your device) answer the question fully locally. The price is maintenance, or doing without team access and document text recognition.
How do you start without overreaching?
With the existing stock, not with structure: make the documents you already have searchable first, then document processes. A searchable archive gets used from day one; an empty wiki doesn’t.